So, mildly inebriated and starving, mister and I decide on a whim to visit the Great Cholesterol Houses of Swanston St right near Flinders St Station. Because, ya know, that's what you do at 8:30 PM on a Thursday or whatever time we decided to go.
We then decided it would be rawrsome (or at least, somewhat delicious) to test out both McD's and HJ's (Burger King for you Americans) nuggets with all their respective sauces. These are our super-scientific, absolutely flawless and impartial findings.
DUN DUN DUUUUUN
Mark fetched all the McD's sauces and I got the HJ's ones, so I could abuse the fuck out of my staff discount. Turns out the girl who served me accidentally gave me a bigger discount than I was entitled to, but then couldn't work out how to fix it and, I dunno, didn't want to involve the manager or something. Whatevs.
Anyway:

These are all the sauces available. Top row is McD's, bottom row is HJ's. Like is aligned with like; the McD's sweet and sour is above the HJ's, ditto BBQ and honey mustard. The others from McD's are sweet mustard and ranch, as well as mayo and generic Heinz ketchup. The first two on the HJ's row are sweet chili and spicy sauces. I didn't get either of the HJs mayo or ranch, because they don't come in pre-packaged containers and I just plain forgot. We didn't end up using ketchup or mayo (ran out of nuggety goodness to test them with), but maybe we'll do a mayo-off another day.

Here are all 24 nuggets in their artery-clogging glory. In the picture, you can't really tell the difference between them. McD's nuggets, however, are a lighter caramel-brown with a sort of thin battered coating, whereas HJ's has sort of breading as well, and is a little darker. I'm not sure if that's because HJ's cooks their nuggets for longer, or whether they just have different coatings, but there you are.

This is what the sauces look like unwrapped. Note how the McD's sweet and sour (s&s) is darker and a different colour than the HJ's, the reverse is true for the honey mustard.

Our super-sciencey way of keeping track of which thingy is which.
Verdict:
Not surprisingly, Mark and I disagreed on a number of points. I think the McD's honey mustard is bollocks, he disagrees; I loved the sweet chili sauce from HJ's, he hated it; he kinda likes the ranch sauce, I can't really bring myself to enjoy it in all its cheesy, mildly barfy glory. But we do agree that:
- McD's makes superior s&s
- HJ's BBQ Plum sauce kicks butt, even though McD's also has nice BBQ sauce — tough call on this one;
- HJ's has better nuggets, they're just a little bit more flavoursome than McD's; and
- McD's sweet mustard sucks.
Mister points out that I waffle on a lot more about the set-up than the actual noms. I say all you need to know is it was delicious, and the images prove that I was totes legit with all the sauces and SCIENCE and stuff, and not just talking shit on McD's even though I'm kinda sorta still employed there. (M: Whatevs)
Feel free to post rebuttals on our experience. Maybe McD's was just having a (really) off day. Maybe HJ's was having an unusually good day — though I've been eating the nuggets there practically every day before work and they've always been this good. Gogo gadget food critic!
Comments [0]